Join TVScoop on Facebook for exclusive competitions and gossip

TV Review: Dawn Porter: My Breasts Could Kill Me, Sky1, Monday 6 July, 9pm

By ShinyMedia on July 7th, 2009 1 comment

dawn-breasts.jpg

Breast cancer is the elephant in the room for many women. Ignorance through fear often seems preferable to the unpalatable truth that one in nine women will, at some point, develop the disease. Add to the mix a family history of breast cancer and a couple of faulty genes, and the liklihood of developing the disease rockets to 80 per cent. For Dawn – whose mother and great-grandmother both died of breast cancer as young women – these statistics must have seemed terrifying. But this very personal documentary two-parter is about much more than scare tactics; it both reinforces the message that knowledge is power and shows there can be life beyond cancer.

For all our Dawn Porter news, reviews and interviews go here


Dawn Porter’s TV exploits have managed to pass me by up until now. Frankly, I’ve had little interest in her explorations into lesbianism and don’t really need telling how traumatic it is becoming a size zero as I get the sweats at the mere thought of giving up my daily Twix. I was sceptical, too, when it came to My Breasts Could Kill Me, mainly because the title inspired thoughts of being chased by a pair of giant boobs with murderous intent.

The first part of this double-header (part two is on Tuesday 7 July, Sky1 9pm) left me conflicted. There were some truly touching moments, like the reassurance Dawn was able to offer a terminally ill mother that her young daughter would remember her – just as Dawn remembered her own mother. There were also inspirational moments, such as the remarkable strength shown by a 23-year-old breast cancer sufferer who had been told by her doctor she had nothing to worry about when she initial found a lump, only for the cancer to spread to her spine.

But this is very much Dawn’s story about her own relationship with the disease, and we were constantly reminded of this with pieces to camera musing on the ifs and buts of her situation as she contemplates her upcoming mammogram. While this did bring home what it must be like to live in the shadow of the disease, it also detracted from the stories of those coping with its day-to-day realities. The lack of tact shown in dealing with the male sufferer was particularly painful to watch, as it only served to reinforce the prevalent belief that this is a ‘woman’s disease’.

What cannot be argued with, though, is the programme’s attempt to shed the cloud of mystery surrounding breast cancer. I had no idea what chemotherapy actually involved and the different affects it can have on patients, and – ashamed as I am to admit it – I had little appreciation of the ‘proper’ way to examine myself. If this message alone can be got across to viewers, then Dawn should be congratulated.

[Miriam Brent]

Join TVScoop on Facebook for exclusive competitions and gossip
  • Anna May

    What was this programme for. Were we really expected to sympathis with Dawn’s ‘maybe’ tumour when contrasted with the women who spoke with such courage about their real treatment and prognosis?
    Also Dawn made such a ridiculous fuss about having a mammogram which may discourage women from getting screened. And worst of all she was given a genetic screen and MRI which are not available to even very high risk patients on the NHS.
    This programme was an exercise in self pity and pouting and exploited the women whose actual stories of breast cancer were reduced to sideshows because of Dawn whinging about something that may or may not ever happen to her.
    She was also seen to abandon the Gerson method after a few hours before she found the coffee enemas too embarrassing.
    This programme was not informative and it wasn’t entertaining.




Related Posts with Thumbnails
Join TVScoop on Facebook for exclusive competitions and gossip