Join TVScoop on Facebook for exclusive competitions and gossip

TV Review: Ashes to Ashes, BBC One, Thursday 7 February, 9pm

By johnberesford on February 7th, 2008 24 comments

a2a_main400.jpgOverdubbed on atmospheric skyline shots of London landmarks, a child’s voice reads Sam Tyler’s original ‘Life on Mars’ intro. The child is Molly, only daughter of DI Alex Drake, and she’s being driven to school on her birthday by her Mum. Tyler died, eventually, in April last year. He deserves a book all to himself and Drake may well be the one to write it. Her thoughts of authorship evaporate when the radio crackles into life with a shout. A gunman has taken a female hostage. Molly relishes the chance to deploy the siren.

The gunman – Arthur Layton – has asked for Drake by name, threatening to shoot his busker hostage unless Drake talks to him. He knows her, but she doesn’t recognise him. You’ve got your mother’s eyes, he tells her, and begins to sing softly under his breath. I’m happy, hope you’re happy too. Molly, scared for her Mum, runs through the barrier and Layton grabs her, drags her away down the steps to the waterside where a shot rings out. Somehow, Molly is safe. She managed to get away. Alex hands her over to her godfather Evan and all returns to safe normality. Except Layton is hiding in Alex’s car. He takes her back to the docks and makes a phone call. She’ll be his ticket out of here, he says, Tim and Caroline Price’s daughter. But whoever he’s calling isn’t impressed, even when he threatens to tell Alex the truth about how her parents died. “I had an empire here,” he whines, “back in the day. Connections.” Alex tries desperately to negotiate with him. She’s a negotiater. It’s what she does. But it doesn’t work on Layton. He puts on his shades and shoots her in the head.


My introduction describes the first nine minutes of the action, but it only took the merest fraction of that nine minutes for me to realise that I’d come home. After all the hype, all the anticipation, the rumours, the snippets of press release that had dripped like slow summer honey from an overfull beehive, this was it. Here it was. And it was glorious. It was perfect. Or, if it wasn’t perfect, then I was incapable of describing or even of imagining how it could have been any better. Then it got better.

Alex wakes up to the sound of Ultravox’s Vienna. She’s aboard a boat party on the Thames, dressed as a prostitute in the company of prostitutes and their clients. A police raid is in progress. Confused by the large quantities of Adam Ant posters lining the dock, she emerges from a tunnel and catches sight of herself reflected in a puddle just as a well-dressed “gentleman” from the boat party catches up with her. He’s not happy. He thinks Alex is responsible for breaking the party up and is about to lay into her when a red Audi Quattro screeches around the bend and skids to a halt in a cloud of dust in front of them. Out steps…Gene Hunt. “Today my friend,” he intones laconically, “your diary entry will read: Took a prozzie hostage and was shot by three armed bastards.”

Alex doesn’t recognise him at first. She’s read about them in Tyler’s notes but she doesn’t know what they look like. She tries to rationalise her surroundings and the events of the last few minutes, spouting a load of psychobabble. “Is it me,” asks Ray, “or are toms getting smarter?”

Then the newly-arrested man calls Gene by name and Gene, in turn, addresses his men. She recognises their names – Chris Skelton, Ray Carling and, yes, Gene Hunt. She faints.

Readers who didn’t watch Life on Mars will have to forgive me. Obviously I’m reviewing this from the point of view of someone who not only watched Life on Mars but was an ardent fan. Indeed, I’d be really interested to hear how this played out for anyone not familiar with the back story. For me though, it was so perfectly handled I’m smiling fit to crack my face at the memory of it. Keeley Hawes captured the semi-confusion of Alex exactly right. She believes it’s all an illusion. A fantasy of her comatose – possibly bullet-damaged – brain. But she recognises it. It’s familiar, but only from the notes. Yet now, it’s real. And the figments of Sam’s imagination are figments of hers too.

They arrive at Met HQ and Alex steps out of the car.

“I can hear the wind in the trees,” she marvels.
“Strewth,” observes Hunt. “She’s gonna break into song.”
“It’s a full sensory hallucination.”

All the criticism I’ve ever levelled at a TV programme, all the moaning I’ve ever done about plot holes and weak dialogue. About scenery imperfections, wooden acting and sloppy direction. What a total joy it was to be able to jettison the lot, for NONE of it applied here. And towering above all the excellence in every aspect of this show was the writing. Care and loving attention to detail shone from every syllable. Tight, witty and totally in character every time. So many gems of humour that it’s hard to count them.

Later, inside the station, Alex makes a discovery: “It’s July 1981. It’s the year my Mum & Dad died.”
“What of?” asks Hunt. “Confusion?”

Although believing she knows how the “fantasy” works, Drake is frustrated by the lack of communication. She believes her mind will “fashion conduits to the real world” much as Sam Tyler experienced, but it’s not happening. The phone call is just a phone call, and the radio is just a radio.

She spots her name plaque on the desk. Unfortunately, to pick it up she has to kneel suggestively in front Gene, much to the delight of the boys. The smile is wiped off their faces when she reveals her warrant card.

They retire to the office to discuss the case, but not before Gene has given an inimitable word of advice to the rest of the department: “I don’t want anyone filling in their arrest diaries, got it? I’ll fill it in for you just as soon as I’ve decided what you were doing.”

The toff from the boat is revealed as Edward Markham, who heads up a drug dealership in the city. They’re about to interview him with an eye to clearing up the entire drug problem on Gene’s patch. Alex though is still distracted by the idea of making contact with the “real world.” She asks Chris where they keep “the most advanced radio in this station.” He takes her to an equipment room and pauses dramatically.

“Wait for it,” he enthuses, opening the door with a flourish.
“Oh, God,” moans Alex
Mistaking her groan for awe, Chris adds: “It’s like Tomorrow’s World in’t it boss?”

Like I said, the whole hour was filled with gems like this. Many of them I didn’t pick up on the first time round. Ashes to Ashes is one series that will pay back your investment in its (eventual) DVD many times over as you catch pearls that flashed by too quickly on first sight.

Gene thinks Markham is the kingpin of the drugs syndicate, but Alex knows he doesn’t fit the psych profile of a leader. Armed with her anachronistic knowledge of Layton (the fact that he told her he had an empire “back in the day”), she knows it’s him, not Markham, who is in charge. But back in 1981 Layton has the perfect cover. In Gene’s words, he’s “a tinker with a minor record.”

Alex stands in front of a whiteboard, trying to make sense of her situation with the help of Chris and Shaz. Her first point of reference is that she was shot which resulted in her arrival in this Dystopia. She writes Dystopia on the board. She believes her mind won’t waste energy in the fantasy inventing things she doesn’t need, so: Everything here is significant. To be able to understand what’s going on, she must constantly Analyse, and since Layton knew her in the future, she must always have been destined to come here. She adds Destiny to the board and is shocked to realise that the initial letters of what she’s written spell DEAD.

Despite what Gene thinks, Alex is certain Layton is the trigger she needs to wake up from 1981 and get back to 2008. They pay him a visit in his junk shop and end up arresting him. In a chilling echo from the future, Layton whines: “Don’t look at me like that. I don’t like it.” They have to release him eventually though. Hunt admits: “As much as it pains me, I think we may need something that will stick in court.”

In conversation with Ray, Alex learns that Sam Tyler came back to 1973, but died in a jewellery bust only the year before she arrived in the past. He drove his car into the river and his body was never found, but he’d been living with Annie, Hunt and the boys for seven years. Alex realises that Sam died in 1980 at exactly the same moment he died in 2007, and Ray’s story confirms his observation that time moves differently for someone “in the past.” Back in 2008, it may only be a second since she’s been shot.

Lunch at Luigi’s provides an excuse for some more excellent music from the 80s (the soundtrack for A2A is shaping up to be every bit as good as LOM), some vibrant visuals, and yet another classic piece of dialogue:

“I invented this world,” mumbles Alex, getting slightly drunk.
“I invented something once,” rejoins Gene. “The bruise-free groin slap.”

Classic.

Drake crashes on the couch to sleep off lunch and half-wakes to find Molly sharing it. “Go sleep in your own bed,” she says grouchily, shoving her away with a hip, before waking up fully with a start to find Molly is gone.

The team try to set Markham and Layton up in a sting operation using Chris and Shaz, but Markham is wise to it. He catches Shaz in the Toledo while Chris is off taking a leak and kidnaps her as “corporate insurance” after beating Chris up. Unable to raise any of the team on the radios, Chris legs it back to the station and mobilises the whole department.

Standing on the banks of the cut, Gene calls the shots:
“Uniform you’re the C Team; DI Drake you lead the B Team; I’m the A Team.”
“God have mercy,” groans Alex at the awful cultural reference.

Across the water, Chris sees Shaz being dragged out of a car, and panics. He heads for the quayside, shouts a warning and opens fire. The thugs have machine guns. Layton tries to escape with Shaz but Gene shoots up the Merc, blowing the radiator. But even with this small victory, Gene is in trouble. He radios Alex: “A Team are cut off. Even I can’t walk on water.”

She gives chase and once again, as was foreshadowed at the start of the story, faces Layton when he’s holding a gun to someone’s head. This time it’s Shaz rather than Molly. Just as things seem desperate the radio crackles back into life: “The A team are back in business.” And indeed they are – in a speedboat with their own machine guns.

Like some local version of James Bond, Hunt lands, gunfire is exchanged, the baddy is banged up and no-one gets hurt. “He’s under arrest! He’s under arrest!” screams Alex to the air, expecting that to be all it needs to release her back to 2008. But it’s not. “Your presence is required around here for just a little bit longer. By me,” admits Gene, clearly impressed with her even though he insists on calling her Bollyknickers.

Back in Alex’s apartment, BBC1 is closing down. As the familiar notes of the National Anthem swell out, she wonders why the television holds no message for her, like it did for Sam. She plays with the radio, which also maintains a frosty silence. “It worked for him,” she muses. “Why won’t it work for me?” And then it does. Barking out “Go to sleep!” and surprising her into dropping it. Molly appears on TV as the clown which has dogged Alex throughout the episode. You’ve just been shot. A second ago. You’re lying on the wet ground. Don’t try to wake up. It’ll hurt too much.

The sight of Molly hardens Alex’s resolve. She records a heartfelt message of defiance and commitment to return, and heads for Luigi’s where the team are enjoying some R&R to the strains of “Nothing Lasts Forever.” She sips the wine Gene pours for her and looks pensive as the credits – artfully done in 1980s “green screen” characters – roll.

How can the team behind A2A have achieved something that simultaneously manages to be the same as LOM but different? I mean it has the same vibe, the same texture, the same wit. But it has a whole different dynamic with Alex replacing Sam, and with the music and culture of the 80s replacing the 70s. I don’t know how they did it, but they did. Apparently there are some saddos somewhere in their crusty, irrelevant garrets tapping out negative criticism of this show. Ignore them. They are as important to our understanding and enjoyment of this show as the scum Gene Hunt grinds under his politically incorrect environmentally unfriendly crocodile skin boot heels. The long wait is over. Ashes to Ashes is here and boy was it worth the wait.

Join TVScoop on Facebook for exclusive competitions and gossip
  • Tone

    The show was p***ing magnificent, unbelievable stuff

  • http://www.genxyblog.com GenXY TV

    Brilliant! Had to have a snigger at how bombastic all of Genes entrances were, I think this show is to LOM what the 80′s were to the 70′s – A brave, bling, over-the-top thing. It was what ‘Aliens’ was to ‘Alien’ the same premise executed in a different way. I loved all of the music and the look of it, great stuff.

  • John

    Greatly enjoyed Gene’s blasting away at Layton with a machine gun, the scenery being shot to bits and sparks flying everywhere. Yet, much like the other A team, not actually killing anyone.

  • http://566610 Rob Davies

    Since when did they have ‘Y’ registered cars in 1981. Apart from that a good watch .Reminded me a bit of the ‘A’ team with loads of machine gun fire and not a single person getting shot.
    Much better than all the other drivel usually on the BBC though.

  • Chris

    This was Average at best, the music intruded on every scene. The terrible acting from Keeley Hawes shouting most of the time in a overly haughty voice just wasn’t interesting, yes she is sexy but so what the 1st series was not about that it was about intrigue and mystery. She simply isn’t believable.
    Previously every episode also had a sub plot in which the action took place, now we seem to have poorly connected scenes nothing else . the actors all appear to have swallowed all the hype from the 1st series and have come back somewhat pompous , nothing has been added and plenty taken away. Chris maybe the only exception to that rule.

    Gene Hunt is still crude yet smart but somehow the lines seem tired and lacking in real wit. The script writers have simply re-hashed similar lines., again no development of character at all.

    I could only just bare to watch this to the end. So very very disappointing.

    Why oh why couldn’t they have a got a decent actress in the main role ? who the heck is she shagging to get this part. What a Terrible shame.

  • http://theworldfromhere.blogspot.com Graeme

    I enjoyed this but the pedant in me spotted the too early Adam Ant look anf the too late BBC One logo.

  • Lavex

    “there are some saddos somewhere in their crusty, irrelevant garrets tapping out negative criticism of this show”

    Little touchy, no?

  • Pete Campbell

    Loved it on the whole as it has been a long year since the fantastic finale to LOM and suffering/ watching mind numbing period drama and reality TV.

    Well spotted that ‘Y’REG cars were 1983 and likewise Adam Ant was 82/83 in his Price Charming guise, I am sure the A Team were not about in 81 either. More Ska/Mod reference would be relevant, I cant understand how the researchers get things so wrong when the nostalgia element is the draw for so many people. It goes without saying that if you were 12 in 1981 like me you are going to rip inaccuracies to shreds!

    Bit perturbed with the “Alien 3″ type “Sam is dead” cop out. Gene’s contemplative glance at the press cutting and the fact the body was never found may hint at a potential twist. How cool would a Sam Tyler cameo be at the end of the series….I wonder if John Simm would go for it though? They all got re-assigned to London a year ago, Sam “died” a year ago both in 1980 and 2007…something is brewing with all that. No mention of Annie yet either…more twists to come methinks.

    Looking forward to next weeks ‘Royal Wedding’ episode..I remember the street party so well!

  • johnberesford

    Fair cop with the Y registration and the incorrect Adam Ant look, but I took the reference to the A Team to be simply something Gene would say (the A Team themselves adopted the name from existing usage). It was Alex who groaned, applying her 2008 sensibilities to the usage. Gene was innocent!

  • http://718757 jason

    Prince Charming by Adam & the Ants was released in May 1981 so they got that absolutely right (I got it for Xmas in December 1981!). Why do people feel the need to slag off shows like this? Thank god the BBC are making stuff like this and Dr Who/Torchwood etc to give us a welcome breath of fresh air from the usual sub soap opera rubbish we normally have to put up with. Great 1st show – it obviously doesn’t feel as fresh as Life on Mars but it is still great stuff with a few new interesting twists. Shame Liz White isn’t in this series though.
    Looking forward to next week’s episode!

  • chris

    Great to see other viewers picked up the y reg plate not being 1981. The whole series has now been undermined by poor research. LOM was a fabulous concept, but pick the bones from it. If you watch the series you will see that the Beeb has reigned in the budget on old cars, they appear on numerous occassions.

  • keiran

    Hi
    just watched ata for the third time.
    You know what-its a stroke of genius,i was a bit disapointed at first,having got meself all physced up,bottle of good red etc! dont get me wrong,i loved it,but something was missing,and it wasnt till i watched it again,i realized i had missed most of the humor in this gem,i was looking for the deep meaning of it all,instead of just enjoying it! this watch brought home the fact that it has the same feel,the sets of the station and genes office,although diffrent,have exactly the same orientation,and claustrophobic feeling about them,the shots in the corridors,were so reminisent of all those cool shots in lom-love it or hate it at the moment? well i bet you will be won over by the end of the series,i think it could be Gene who was behind the death of alexes parents mmmmmmmm!

  • Hays

    Having watched 2 eps of AtA, I have to say that I am very disapointed. Think Keeley Hawes is completely unconvincing. Maybe it would have worked better if her character hadn’t read Sam’s report..? The male characters are excellent as usual, although It seems wrong for Gene to hang out in a cafe/restaurant. It would have made more sense if he had hung out at a local pub again drinking beer and scotch. Also WPC Sharon seems to serve no point to the story. It just seems like she has been added into the script at the last minutes because the directors thought they should have another female actress.

    I will try a few more eps before I turn off, although judging from the first two, I doubt I will be buying the dvd!

  • Gerry

    Guys, please let’s get real – LOM was great, I loved it… but this is so poor that it will be the first and last series. I was cringing at everything, the “acting” of Keeley Hawes, the “plot” – the exaggerated focus on the car and the VERY silly boat shooting scene … it just didn’t work for me – very disappointed (after trying to watch the second part – and failed – I deleted the rest I had recorded)
    Maybe it’s just me …

  • Christie

    I was so disappointed with this. It felt like all the actors had become characterisations. And Keely Hawes is just the most dreadful actress possibly on the planet!
    I saw her on Jonathan Ross and she was awful on that too – came across as really empty. Poor show. Sometimes it’s better to leave things alone.

  • Hays

    Absolutely Christie, Keeley Hawes is terrible. Everyone I have discussed ATA with has said the same thing. There are so many talented actors out there, it’s such a shame they chose her. After watching a few eps, it seems like the characters are becoming characatures and can there be any more inuendos in there-it’s becoming more and more like a carry on film.

  • Hays

    Absoultely. There are so many talented actors out there, I am not sure why they chose Keeley Hawes. also the male characters are becoming characatures and there are far too many inuendos in the script- it isn’t a carry on film!

  • PieroPizza

    …this is from Italy…glad to see again Gene Hunt on tv,glad to see the sequel of an amazing show,glad to hear the music of my youth…my best compliments…

  • Jimbo

    Keeley Hawes is terrible and ruins the whole show, bring back Sam Tyler! :-)

  • Chico Copp

    Mmmmm I gave up on it after 3 episodes, forgot it was on one week and never bothered with it again, for me it just isn’t working as well as ‘Life on Mars’ did….now that show grabbed me by the ghoolies and hung on. I’m afraid Ashes to Ashes looks contrived & forced….o real feeling for the ’80′s’ and is relying on the good feeling left over from the LOM. Now what would have grabbed me would have been if Hunt had been transported forward in time from the 70s to the present….having to cope with our modern ways….THAT would have been amazing!!

  • makhan Dhinsa

    This show is top quality rubbish–it is clear the BBC has made big cut backs. Acting is shallow, the plots lack any aesthetic value and it is just not good enough to warrant being a sequel to life on mars.
    This is BBC at its best?

  • incorrigible

    I’m sorry – but it seems that the ‘critics’ are missing something. A2A is an ENTERTAINMENT! I too was around in that period and it doesn’t mean a jot to me if there are mistakes. The feel of the show is perfect, The characters from LOM fleshed out even more and give poor Keeley a break! For me the present series will be over all too soon. And I will miss them all. Please, just enjoy it for what it is – if you can’t, go watch open University or do the dishes for your wife ‘partner’. Stop getting your ‘bolly’ knickers in a twist.

  • Debbie

    Yes, I agree, the “critics” of A2A are definitely missing something. Alex Drake is in a part fantasy/part memory world so facts won’t be always be correct (she can do whatever she wants in her fantasy). I loved both LOM and A2A and thought Keeley Hawes was great and funny too – remember, it IS a bit tongue-in-cheek.

  • chris

    I recorded all the episodes and have deleted them one by one as I have watched them. I have finally deleted the last one with a sense of relief.

    LOM was a brilliant series and one that I could happily watch again and again. This series had no point. Whereas the last series was a comparison of policing in the late 60s early 70s with Sam bringing modern techniques to that era, AtA brings out none of that. In fact Gene Hunt is showing some clueless police officer / psychologist how to police rather than the other way round.

    The bits with her parents are toe curlingly, walk out of the room, bad and you end up hoping that she will get killed in the explosion too so that we don’t have to endure any more of this. I’m not sure if it is her bad acting, apalling script writing or ill-thought out plots but this series simply didn’t work at all. There was little or no suspense in any of the episodes and you really didn’t care about any of the characters. Even Gene Hunt’s one liners couldn’t lift this show out of the mire.




Related Posts with Thumbnails
Join TVScoop on Facebook for exclusive competitions and gossip